12A Railway Colony Review: Allari Naresh’s Uneven Murder Mystery
Allari Naresh, long celebrated for his comedy timing, has gradually been exploring more serious roles. 12A Railway Colony sees him venturing into completely new territory—a murder mystery. For audiences accustomed to seeing him in light-hearted roles, this film offers a fresh, albeit uneven, experience.
Story:
Karthik (Allari Naresh) works as a henchman for Warangal politician Tillu. He is deeply in love with his neighbour, Aaradhana (Kamakshi Bhaskarla), an aspiring sportsperson living with her mother. One day, while hiding something in Aaradhana’s house, Karthik is shocked to find both her and her mother dead. Who is behind the murders? And if Aaradhana was already dead, who did Karthik see at her doorstep earlier?
Teaming up with police officer Rana Pratap (Sai Kumar), Karthik’s investigation uncovers a series of startling revelations that drive the rest of the story.
Performances:
Allari Naresh adopts the Telangana dialect for this role, but his performance feels strained despite his sincere effort. Kamakshi Bhaskarla is limited by a wafer-thin role and delivers a routine performance. Sai Kumar talks more than he investigates, though Abhirami impresses in a crucial supporting role. Anish Kuruvilla is effective as the doctor, while Viva Harsha provides adequate comic relief. Jeevan Kumar fits the politician’s part well, and Madhumani brings authenticity as Aaradhana’s mother.
Technical Aspects:
On the technical front, there’s little to commend beyond the production design. Cinematography, music, and visual effects are underwhelming, and editing is uneven. The writing lacks depth and originality, making the narrative feel flat. Two songs are included, but neither leaves an impression.
Highlights:
- Some plot twists
- The climactic moments
Drawbacks:
- First half is slow and dull
- Superficial investigation
- Weak pacing and narrative direction
Analysis:
Dr. Anil Vishwanath, who made an impact with Polimera, serves as the writer and “showrunner” for 12A Railway Colony, while editor Nani directs. Unfortunately, the film struggles to recreate the intrigue of his earlier work.
The first half drags painfully, with little happening until the interval when the hero discovers the heroine’s death. Even then, the narrative momentum is just beginning to build. The actual plot unfolds only in the second half, but its twists and the revelation of the killer fail to generate real excitement. Subplots involving a doctor and a politician add some interest, but the investigation often feels unconvincing. Attempts to incorporate ghost-thriller elements appear forced and out of place.
Overall, 12A Railway Colony suffers from a weak narrative spine. The surprises don’t land, the ghost elements feel tacked on, and the story around the motive isn’t engaging enough. Even Allari Naresh, trying a serious role, feels miscast in this genre.
Bottom Line:
12A Railway Colony is an average murder mystery with minor twists. It lacks the thrills and tension required to keep audiences hooked, falling short of the benchmark set by Polimera.
