A Reddit post by an Indian-American citizen has ignited a vigorous online debate by drawing parallels between the evolving U.S. immigration system and the Gulf model, particularly in how it affects skilled Indian professionals. Titled “For Indians, USA is becoming more like Dubai,” the post outlines the user’s decade-long journey from an F1 student visa to H1B, then a green card, and finally U.S. citizenship.
The user expressed concern over the increasingly restrictive nature of the legal immigration system, noting that even top-tier applicants under the EB1 category now face estimated wait times of 10–15 years due to systemic backlogs. They highlighted how recent policy shifts, including wage-based visa allocations and stricter pathways from student to work visas, are pushing many Indian professionals to treat the U.S. as a temporary financial opportunity rather than a permanent home — echoing the migratory experience in Gulf countries.
The post sparked a range of responses. Some users echoed the frustrations, pointing to inefficiencies, outdated per-country caps, and the disconnect between immigration policy and labor market needs. Others criticized what they viewed as an entitled perspective, arguing that U.S. immigration policy must prioritize national interest rather than serve as a solution to employment challenges in India.
A subset of commenters also raised concerns about abuse of the H1B system, including allegations of fake credentials and unqualified applicants. Meanwhile, others defended skilled Indian workers, asserting that the system’s flaws are structural, not individual.
This online discourse underscores the growing complexities and pressures facing high-skilled Indian immigrants in the United States, as the country reconsiders its legal migration frameworks under evolving political and economic imperatives.
Recent Random Post:
